How To Make Peanut Butter Pie

This post may contain affiliate links. Read our disclosure policy here.

Who loves peanut butter?

I sure do! I love peanut butter. A lot. When I first married my husband, he was very grossed out by peanut butter. The taste, the texture, how it felt in his mouth. But of course, it grew on him since I made and bought a variety of foods with peanut butter in them.

The other day I made a peanut butter pie. So easy. No baking involved (unless you make your own pie crust, like I did). Even though it is called peanut butter pie, I think it more like a peanut butter cheesecake. Mmmmmm. So yummy! Here’s how to make peanut butter pie:

Peanut Butter Pie

What You Need:


  • Beat together sugar & cream cheese.
  • Mix in the milk & peanut butter.
  • Beat until smooth.
  • Fold in whipped cream.


  • Scoop into pie crust.
  • Sprinkle Reese’s crumbs on top.
  • Cover & freeze.
  • Take out a few minutes before serving.
  • And that’s how to make peanut butter pie!


I have seen this pie made a variety of ways. Some make it fluffier and don’t freeze it. Others use an Oreo pie crust. Or top the pie with whipped topping. Maybe one day I will try other methods. But I like this pie just the way it is.

Will you try this peanut butter pie?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Support Little House Living by Sharing This

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. This sounds really good! Just one question, the directions say to beat together the sugar and cream cheese. How much sugar? I don’t see it on the ingredient list. Thanks.

  2. Mmm that looks delicious! My husband and kids LOVE peanut butter. Maybe ill make this for fathers day.

  3. Hi Erin, I make a peanut butter pie, however I want to try yours I think I might like it better but like Arlisa above mentioned I don’t see how much sugar to add. It’s not listed in the ingredients. Can you add the amount or post it? Thank you so much, sounds so yummy!!

    1. It is a 1.5 cups of confectioners sugar.

      —don’t know how I forgot to include that important ingredient to the post!

      Hope that helps. Enjoy!

  4. I just made it and it is fantastic! I omitted the 1/2 c of milk for a thicker texture so I could serve it right away, it was a hit. Thank you.

  5. Wishing you a peaceful Memorial Day Weekend and thank you so much for sharing with Full Plate Thursday.
    Come Back Soon!
    Miz Helen

  6. I am SO glad you shared this at Pinworthy Projects! I have a slight obsession with peanut butter and chocolate!

  7. ABSOLUTELY hilarious about your husband not liking peanut butter when you first got married – SAME HERE!! But, I’m not so happy that he has started liking it because now I have to share all those peanut butter and chocolate delights – like this pie or a bowl of ice cream! Lol!

  8. I am agreement with you…..the pie looks and sounds amazing just the way it is. I am not a fan of peanut butter on it’s own. I will never eat a peanut butte sandwich, of on crackers..but my favorite candy is Reese’s Peanut butter cups and I think peanut butter cookies are the best ever. This pie looks amazing, pinning it to make soon, I am sure I will love it. Thank you so much for sharing it.