We Stopped Buying These Grocery Items and Our Bill Dropped Fast
This post may contain affiliate links. Read our disclosure policy.
It wasn’t one big “budget hack.” It was a handful of grocery items we quietly stopped buying—because they’re the same items that make your cart expensive without feeding your family any better.
The funny part? Most of them are marketed as “convenient.” But once we started making a few pantry swaps (the kind you can stash in jars), our grocery total dropped fast—and weeknight dinners got easier, not harder.
Here are the grocery items we stopped buying first (and exactly what we replaced them with).
1) Boxed “Helper” dinners
These are the classic “I’m tired and I need dinner” boxes. The cost adds up quickly, and they’re basically pasta + seasoning + a sauce packet.
What we do instead: keep a jar of DIY mix on the shelf and cook it the same way—brown meat, add the jar, add liquids, simmer.
DIY swap: Homemade Hamburger Helper Mix
Why it saves: you’re paying for pantry staples (pasta + spices) instead of packaging, branding, and “mystery convenience.” It also makes it easy to double or triple batches when ground beef is on sale.
Make-it-even-easier tip: When you mix jars, do 4–6 at once. One mess. A month of “backup dinners.”
2) Canned condensed cream soups
Cream of chicken. Cream of mushroom. Cream of… everything. They’re the backbone of so many casseroles, but the price per can has gotten painful.
What we do instead: keep a dry cream-of-soup mix in a jar and turn it into whatever “cream soup” we need when it’s time to cook.
DIY swap: Homemade Cream of Soup Mix (with variations)
Why it saves: this one swap replaces a stack of cans over time. And because it’s a dry pantry mix, you can scale it up when you find dry milk and broth powder at a good price.
3) Boxed Rice-a-Roni (and “flavored rice” sides)
These boxes don’t look expensive… until you buy a few a week. They’re also one of those items that disappear fast because they’re an “easy side.”
What we do instead: jar up a Rice-a-Roni style mix once and keep it on hand for quick sides—or to bulk up soups and meals.
DIY swap: Homemade Rice-a-Roni Mix
Why it saves: you can buy rice and pasta in bulk and make multiple jars for the price of a few boxes. It’s also easier to adjust salt and seasonings for picky eaters.
4) Instant oatmeal packets
They’re convenient… and somehow you can go through a whole box without anyone feeling like they ate a real breakfast.
What we do instead: make our own “packets” (bags or small jars). Same idea. Much cheaper. No weird flavors you didn’t choose.
DIY swap: Homemade Instant Oatmeal Packets
Why it saves: oats are one of the most budget-friendly staples you can buy, especially in larger bags. You’re no longer paying packet-pricing for something that takes 30 seconds to assemble yourself.
5) Pancake/waffle mix
This is one of those sneaky ones because it feels cheap. But if you make pancakes often (or do breakfast-for-dinner), the mix adds up—especially if you’re buying “just add water” versions.
What we do instead: keep a bulk pancake/waffle mix ready to go in a large jar or container.
DIY swap: Homemade Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix
Why it saves: flour + leavening + pantry basics are dramatically cheaper per batch than boxed mixes, and you can make enough for many breakfasts in one quick prep session.
6) Seasoning packets you “have to buy again” every week
Ranch packets. Dip packets. “Special” blends. They’re small, but they’re constant.
What we do instead: mix up a jar once and refill it as needed. We use it for dressing, seasoning, dips, and quick flavor boosts.
Why it saves: packets are convenience-priced. A jar of homemade seasoning lasts longer and costs less (especially if you buy spices in larger containers).
7) “Just add water” soup packets
Soup packets seem helpful in winter… until you realize they’re mostly salt, noodles, and tiny bits of seasoning.
What we do instead: layer soup mixes in jars. They look pretty on the shelf, but more importantly, they turn into real meals.
DIY swap: DIY Dry Soup Mixes (how to make + store)
Why it saves: dried beans, lentils, pasta, and spices are far cheaper when you assemble them yourself. Plus, you can control salt and tailor mixes to your family’s favorites.
It wasn’t one change
If you only do one swap, start with the item you buy most often—because frequency is what quietly drains a grocery budget.
My easiest starting point: pick one jar mix to prep this week, then replace that one store item every time you shop. Once that feels normal, add the next.
If you want a simple starting list of pantry-friendly mixes, this is the best hub to pull from:
DIY Convenience Foods That Save Money (all the links in one place)
Tip: If you want this to be truly “set it and forget it,” make 3–6 jars at a time. One kitchen mess. Weeks of cheaper convenience.